About

Assurance Property Management & Realty Inc. is a full-service real estate and property management firm headquartered in New Paris, Indiana. Located at 19097 County Road 46, New Paris, IN 46553, we serve Elkhart County, Kosciusko County, and surrounding regions. 

With decades of local experience, Assurance combines deep regional knowledge with a client-first approach to real estate services and property oversight. Whether you're buying or selling a home, managing rental properties, or investing in real estate, our mission is to offer dependable, personalized service built on integrity, transparency, and accountability.

Our Services

• Property Management — We provide end-to-end management for residential, multifamily, and commercial properties. From tenant screening and leasing to maintenance coordination and financial reporting, we handle the day-to-day so that property owners can relax knowing their investments are in capable hands.

• Real Estate Brokerage — Our licensed agents assist clients in buying and selling properties across our service area. We guide clients through everything from market analysis and pricing to negotiation and closing.

Our Team

Led by Michelle “Shelley” Tucker, our team blends professionalism, ethics, and local insight. Shelley has a strong track record in residential real estate across Elkhart and Kosciusko counties and has worked extensively in property management.  

Why Choose Assurance?

• Local Roots: As a locally based firm, we understand the nuances of the Indiana real estate and rental markets.

• Transparent Approach: We believe in clear communication, fair practices, and keeping clients fully informed.

• Reliability & Integrity: From handling tenant issues promptly to accurate accounting and maintenance oversight, we aim to deliver trustworthy performance.

• Comprehensive Support: Whether you’re new to property investment or a seasoned landlord, we scale our services to match your needs.

At Assurance Property Management & Realty Inc., we don’t just manage properties or close deals — we build relationships and help dreams become home. Reach out to us and let us show how we can support your real estate goals.